Falling Free, Lois McMaster Bujold

Written by Natalie Luhrs

I'm a lifelong geek with a passion for books and social justice.

Filed Under:

Tagged With:

June 5, 2013

Falling Free, Lois McMaster Bujold

Falling Free, Lois McMaster Bujold

It has been at least a decade since I’d read Lois McMaster Bujold’s Falling Free and I wish it hadn’t taken me so long to get around to it for lo, it is awesome.

I had always thought of it as a relatively minor Bujold novel and on this reading I discovered that I was very, very wrong. I’m not saying it is the very best Bujold novel, but it’s definitely moved into my top five (the others: Paladin of Souls, Memory, Komarr/A Civil Campaign, Barrayar okay I am totally cheating here by combining two–I can’t pick just five!).

The reason I decided to pick this up was a need to use my Audible credits–I was going on a long train trip and wanted a few choices in audiobooks. Between the two credits I had and a mystery coupon that was in my account, I managed to get three audiobooks for about $3 (plus my monthly membership fee, of course). I’d heard good things about Grover Gardner’s narration, I was in the mood for something short, so I picked it up. And after listening to the first two hours last Friday I decided that I needed to read it faster than I could listen to it and happily discovered that Falling Free was included in the omnibus Miles, Mutants, and Microbes that I’d picked up a few years ago shortly after I got my first e-reader.

The plot of the book is extremely straight forward: Leo Graf, welding engineer, is sent out to the back end of nowhere to teach a class on non-destructive testing techniques. When he arrives, he discovers that he’s been specially requested by one of his former students, someone he booted up to administration for very good reasons (involving people being promoted up to their level of incompetence). He also discovers that his students are a group of genetically modified humans–modified so heavily that they are an entirely different species of human.

Instead of legs, they have arms–two pairs. Known as quaddies, they also have other modifications that allow them to thrive in zero-gee conditions. They’re also, legally, not people. They’re the property of a large engineering firm, GalacTech.

And that’s where the problems start. Because Leo does see them as people and it is through his eyes that the reader does, too. As Leo gets to know the quaddies, so do we. And they are just a bunch of kids–the oldest among them are just 20 years old and the GalacTech personnel in charge of their upbringing have done their best to mold them into the shape they want and need them to be. This involves heavily revisionist history, total lack of privacy, and a general ban on fiction and other media.

Then it all goes haywire–two quaddies, Tony and Claire, were told to make a baby. And they did, and in the process, they became pair-bonded. And when Claire’s “production schedule” is accelerated and Tony isn’t involved…well. Things get interesting fast. So interesting that reproductive choice is the trigger event for everything else that follows–this is something that’s a theme in Bujold’s other work, too.

This really is an amazing and wonderful book. It’s fast-paced and the quaddies are so very interesting–and you can see the seeds that Bujold planted in this book for what quaddie culture becomes when we encounter it again 200 years later during Miles Vorkosigan’s lifetime. The beginnings their dance and musical forms are here, as are their naming conventions and everything about their entire society. Bujold even slips in a bit about accommodations; at one point when Silver is in an environment with gravity, she reflects that it wouldn’t be so bad if only the seat were shaped properly.

I also really love this book because of Leo Graf. He’s an engineer through and through and approaches everything as if it’s an engineering problem, even as he’s figuring out how to help the quaddies grab their freedom with all four hands and not let go.

My favorite bit is one near the end involving a work permit. Or the earlier bit with the inspection record. Or maybe the point at which Leo throws in with the quaddies fully:

The solution had been lying around him in pieces all this time, invisible until he’d changed. He grinned dementedly, possessed. He yielded himself up to it without reservation. All. All. There was no limit to what one man might do, if he gave all, and held back nothing.

Didn’t hold back, didn’t look back–for there would be no going back. Literally, medically, that was the heart of it. Men adapted to free fall, it was the going back that crippled them.

I am a quaddie,” Leo whispered in wonder. He regarded his hands, clenched and spread his fingers. “Just a quaddie with legs.” He wasn’t going back.

Leo and Cazaril (from The Curse of Chalion) are, I think, cousins of a sort.

I think if I talk too much more about this book I’ll end up giving it all away or typing in all my favorite bits (which is like 30% of the book, at least) and no one wants that so I’ll just say that Bujold is doing so many interesting things in this book–she’s talking about privilege and what it means to be a person and integrity and so many of the other themes that echo throughout her entire body of work. Ethics is another huge theme here–how much genetic manipulation is too much? Is it possible to go too far?

There is one thing that confuses me, though. Why on earth has this book been repeatedly nominated for a Prometheus Hall of Fame Award? There’s nothing remotely libertarian about it–in fact, I would say that the principles it espouses are about as far away from libertarianism as possible. The quaddies share everything–they have very little private property and their entire society is set up as an interdependent system because that is the only way they’re going to survive. Quaddies, literally, cannot make it on their own–their natural environment precludes that as a possibility.

If you haven’t read this book, you really need to. It’s wonderful in every way a book by Bujold can be wonderful.

You may also like…

Recent Reading, January 2021

Recent Reading, January 2021

I've been doing a fair amount of reading these days, which has been really great. I feel like I've found my reading...


  1. Selki

    I should re-read that. I’ve enjoyed the references to it in her later works. I remember enjoying Leo’s engineering approach, too.

    • Natalie

      I really appreciated the engineering stuff a lot more this time around–I think the first time I read it, a lot of the very specific engineering stuff flew over my head.

      Although from a cost control perspective, LMB did make one error: at one point she refers to the quaddies as capital equipment and then as an R&D project. They can’t be both simultaneously. If we see them as not-people (as GalacTech does), then while they are still in the R&D phase, they are a pilot project and, therefore cost. Once they go into production (i.e., the first contract at Kline Station), then THOSE quaddies will become capital equipment–and will depreciate over their lifetimes. The ones who are still growing up and being trained are still cost items, though. I think.

      There’s also a manufacturing component to this–quaddies such as Claire, who are destined for reproductive careers (*shudder*) are actually production facilities and any dollars spent to maintain them at that point are maintenance cost, not R&D or capital. And each quaddie infant would then be its own project with its own facesheet to track costs.

      I may be thinking about this entirely too much now.

  2. Jessica

    I was so excited about this book when I read your review. I love the idea of a consideration of what makes a person a person, what counts as a disability, and the repression of reproductive freedom.

    But now I see from your comment that this author has not written a totally accurate book from a cost control perspective.

    I’m out.


    • Natalie

      *snicker* It’s actually a very subtle error.

      I really am interested in your perspective on this from an ethics POV. I think there’s a lot of crunchy stuff in there. And it also has almost no other connection to the rest of the Vorkosiverse books so no spoilers.

  3. --E

    It’s always interesting to see which LMB books people choose as their favorites. There seem to be clear divisions, where people on one side say, “Yes, those are great, but my faves are these,” and people on the other side say the exact same thing, but with the opposite groups of books.

    So, your picks are all great, but my faves are these: Falling Free, Barrayar, Curse of Chalion, and above all others, Mirror Dance.

    It actually took me three tries to get into Mirror Dance, no joke. And by the end, I was all BEST BOOK EVER!!! and just loved it to pieces because of how brilliantly she structured it.

    Then there are things such as A Civil Campaign which has one of the most hilarious scenes ever committed to text (the bug-butter fight), and is a very enjoyable read overall, but which doesn’t scratch my personal itches. Similarly with Paladin of Souls, which many people adore. I thought it was a great book, but not as compelling to me as other LMB.

    • Natalie

      I really need to reread the books set earlier in the continuity. It’s been a long, long time since I have–and I suspect that my picks may change once I do since I am not the same person now as I was when I read them first.

      For me, what makes A Civil Campaign is the apology. I think Bujold does emotional truth extraordinarily well and that’s one reason I enjoy her work so much.

  4. --E

    Hmm. I think the divisions are this:

    Mirror Dance + Curse of Chalion
    Memory + Paladin of Souls.

    Everyone agrees all four are spectacular, but most people prefer one pair over the other. I don’t think I’ve ever encountered someone who mixed those pairings (i.e. Mirror Dance + Paladin, or Memory + Curse).

  5. Selki

    Natalie: I *enjoy* your cost-control geekery perspective, and would enjoy seeing it in more reviews! 🙂

  6. Erica

    E – I’m a Mirror Dance/Paladin preferrer (although Memory and Curse are so close, it’s difficult to choose really). I agree about the structure of Mirror Dance (I did a whole post about it – http://hedda62.dreamwidth.org/4058.html) and the development of Mark’s character is fantastic, and I suppose I feel similarly about Ista’s self-discovery – anyway, definitely my two top Bujold novels.

    Natalie, wonderful review – must read Falling Free again…

    • Natalie

      Oh my goodness, it’s been a long time, Erica! Things still bompstable? (I think I’m remembering correctly that you used to be on LP, right?)

      I’m definitely going to have to reread Mirror Dance now.

  7. Erica

    @Natalie: Yeah, that’s me, hi Natalie! I’ve been reading this blog for a while (found it through Donna) but of course it took Bujold to make me comment. Great job!


  1. Rescue Me? Falling Free, by Lois McMaster Bujold | Something More - [...] I think Shards of Honor was a great entry point for me, but recent reviews by Kaetrin and Natalie made me rethink skipping Falling…


Words of Wisdom

"It's chaos, be kind."
Michelle McNamara